House of Cards Uses Anti-Semitism As Plot Line » ADL Blogs
News & Perspectives on Anti-Semitism in the U.S. and Abroad
February 6, 2013 4

House of Cards Uses Anti-Semitism As Plot Line

For us at the Anti-Defamation League, the old Madi­son Avenue line “as long as they spell my name right” par­tially applies to the new mini-series “House of Cards,” being aired on Net­flix.  The series stars Kevin Spacey as the schem­ing and con­niv­ing Demo­c­ra­tic whip of the House of Rep­re­sen­ta­tives.  In two scenes ADL is briefly mentioned.

Credit: Reuters/Melinda Sue Gordon/Neftlix/Handout

In the first, Spacey’s char­ac­ter calls ADL after it is revealed that the president’s choice for Sec­re­tary of State crit­i­cized Israel’s “ille­gal occu­pa­tion” of Pales­tin­ian land in an edi­to­r­ial 30 years ago when he was the edi­tor of his col­lege stu­dent newspaper.

In the sec­ond scene, the fic­tional head of ADL is shown telling a press gag­gle that “he’s an anti-Semite” for say­ing those words.

On one level, we see it as a form of flat­tery that the cre­ators of the pro­gram thought of ADL for such a theme.  This reflects well as to recog­ni­tion of our out­spo­ken­ness regard­ing unjust crit­i­cism of Israel and tes­ti­fies to our wide name recognition.

On the other hand, it plays into an image of ADL which dis­torts who we are. It sug­gests, as some do, that ADL will call any­one who crit­i­cizes Israel an anti-Semite with the con­nected impli­ca­tion that we are try­ing to sti­fle legit­i­mate crit­i­cism of Israel.

The truth is that we would be sharply crit­i­cal of some­one who refers to Israel’s sit­u­a­tion in the West Bank as “ille­gal occu­pa­tion” but would not refer to such an indi­vid­ual as anti-Semite unless there were other things he had said, whether dele­git­imiz­ing Israel or com­par­ing Israel to Nazis or accus­ing Israel of crimes that fall under the cat­e­gory of blood libels and conspiracies.

Crit­i­cism of Israel some­times may be legit­i­mate, some­times not. When it is not, it may or may not rise to the level of anti-Semitism.

We under­stand that “House of Cards” is fic­tion so we have no inter­est in protest­ing.  But the more nuanced view that we have just described is the real ADL, an orga­ni­za­tion to whom cred­i­bil­ity is every­thing and one that makes sure that the term anti-Semitic is used when it is truly warranted.

  • It must be com­fort­able for those who are crit­i­cised to be able to decide what is “legit­i­mate” crit­i­cism and not.

  • If you do exactly what you say you do in this arti­cle, then I have no com­plaints. I believe that it is an occu­pa­tion, although not an ille­gal one, but Israel does many ille­gal things there. These are mere vio­la­tions of the Geneva Con­ven­tions, not blood libels. Things like using phos­pho­rous in urban areas, set­tling it’s pop­u­la­tion in occu­pied ter­ri­tory, demol­ish­ing the prop­erty of the peo­ple in the occu­pied ter­ri­tory despite a duty to pro­tect the same, killing unarmed civil­ians wav­ing a white flag, and so on. To be fair, I think they pros­e­cuted some­one for that last offence. I am on record as say­ing that Israel is not as bad as the Nazis, which is a favourable comparison.

  • O dog

    Why would you be sharply crit­i­cal of the claim that Israels pres­ence in the wb is an ille­gal occu­pa­tion? That is the posi­tion of most of the world out­side of the Israeli right and the docile US polit­i­cal estab­lish­ment. Even Israels supreme co calls it “bel­liger­ent occu­pa­tion”. You’d best sharpen your pen­cil because Europe, Latam, Asia, rus­sia, the un, not to men­tion the arab world, have long reached con­sen­sus: Israel is ille­gally occu­py­ing the West Bank.

    • AK_Jonesy

      It’s not the opin­ion of the US polit­i­cal Estab­lish­ment, and I’m get­ting sick of peo­ple that rep­re­sent 5% or less of our coun­try claim­ing they’re the 99% or they rep­re­sent all Americans.

      MOST Amer­i­cans are hon­or­able peo­ple, we respect our allies and our alliances. Israel is, has been, and will con­tinue to be our ally. The major­ity of Amer­i­cas are not stu­pid, under­e­d­u­cated, brain­washed col­lege children.

      Fur­ther­more you don’t seem to under­stand in regards to Europe, Latam?, Asia, and Rus­sia– America’s motto isn’t ‘E pluribus unim’ it’s ‘We’re Amer­i­can, and we really don’t give a **** what you think’